EVOC

Menu 
  • Home
  • About EVOC
    • Edinburgh Third Sector Interface
    • Membership
      • EVOC Membership Form
    • Annual Reports and Statements
    • Vacancies
    • EVOC Publications
      • Reports
    • Board of Directors
    • EVOC News
    • Meet the EVOC Team
    • EVOC Blog
    • The Red Book
    • Get On Board Edinburgh
  • Training
    • Course programme
    • Training Grants
  • Grants
  • Need Help?
  • Networks
    • Children, Young People and Families
      • About the Network
      • Meeting papers
      • Papers from previous meetings
      • Network Representation
      • Getting it right for every child in Edinburgh
      • Early Years Change Fund
        • Early Years Change Fund – Development Fund
    • ECTOG
      • Edinburgh Disability Forum
      • Older People Service Providers
        • Resources
        • Meeting Papers
        • Papers from previous meetings
    • Edinburgh Mental Health Forum
      • Resources
    • Recovery Essentials Financial Inclusion Project
      • Project Partners
      • Project Background
    • Substance Use Network Edinburgh (SUNE)
      • Network reps feedback forms
      • Resources
      • Meeting papers
      • Meeting papers archive
    • Voluntary Sector Forums
  • Partnership
    • Edinburgh Partnership Family
      • Strategic Partnerships
        • Children’s Partnership
        • Compact Partnership
        • Community Safety
        • Economic Development Strategic Partnership
      • Cross-cutting Partnerships
        • Sustainable Development Partnership
      • Neighbourhood Partnerships
    • Third Sector Strategy Group (TSSG)
      • Implementation Group Inspiring Volunteering in Edinburgh (iGIVE)
      • ESE
      • Edinburgh Health and Social Care Partnership (IJB)
        • Health Inequalities Standing Group
        • Edinburgh IJB Grants Review 2018
    • greenspace : artspace
    • The Early Years Collaborative
    • LOOPs
      • Meeting Papers
      • Meeting Dates
      • LOOPs Hospital Discharge Support Programme
  • Noticeboard
    • About Noticeboard
      • Submissions guidelines
      • Submission form
    • Categories
      • Children and young people
      • Consultations and Events
      • Funding
      • Disabilities
      • Local Opportunities for Older People (LOOPs)
      • Mental Health & Wellbeing
      • Miscellaneous
      • News and Information
      • Recruitment
      • Resources
      • Training
  • thinkSpace
    • Events Programme
    • Previous Events
    • Surveys
  • Information
    • Volunteering and Social Security – final partnership offer and DWP Guidance
    • City of Edinburgh Council Budget
    • Funding and Fundraising Regulations
    • Transformation Programme
    • Localities
    • Participatory Budgeting
    • Welfare reform
      • Current Resources
      • Welfare Reform – New powers for Scotland
  • Contact Us
    • Maps & Directions
    • Get in Touch
You are here: Home » Blog Posts » Councillors stand by coproduction – Maria Arnold

Councillors stand by coproduction – Maria Arnold

19 December 2016

Should deaf people have a say in the way services for deaf people are run? A resounding yes was the answer from Edinburgh’s Finance and Resource Committee on 1st December.

Current provider Deaf Action had raised issues at the previous committee meeting in November when the recommendation had been made to approve the appointment of three private sector organisations, to a framework agreement for British Sign Language interpretation to help deaf people access health and social care services. They felt that the way the specification had been developed without meaningful consultation with deaf people didn’t recognise the nuances of delivering effective British Sign Language interpretation.

The issues are complex, and you can watch the deputations on the links below. Edinburgh Voluntary Organisations’ Council (EVOC) were asked to add our perspective following the initial debate. While not experts in the specifics of the service, we recognised a number of fundamental issues with the broad processes involved, largely the failure to give deaf people the chance to feed into the way services for deaf people are delivered, and the lack of a robust Equalities and Rights Impact Assessment.

Given the level of vulnerability of this group of service users, the barriers they face in accessing health and social care services, and the implications for health inequalities we felt contributing this debate was particularly pertinent. Health inequalities is a consistent problem, but it’s not always easy to identify measures that might make a real difference. Doing everything to make sure that barriers faced by deaf people are reduced should certainly be a top priority.

We recognise the position council officers are in, with massively reduced resources and colleagues regularly leaving at short notice. This process had definitely suffered from staff fluctuations, and the services had not been commissioned under the health and social care framework, where meaningful involvement of service users is becoming standard. It is hard to admit mistakes and agree to start over, and it’s to the credit of all involved that there was an openness to doing just this. While council officers were keen to be clear that the process was legal and correct, they readily admitted that there were elements which could be much improved, and that these being done better might have a fundamental impact on the quality of service provided.

Following an amendment proposed by Green Councillor Gavin Corbett, committee members took the welcome decision to recognise the shortcomings of the current specification and recommend that the commissioning process is repeated, this time putting service users at the very centre. EVOC look forward to being a part of this and helping to make sure that it is an exemplar of coproduction.

We still have some way to go, especially as regards procurement practices, but this decision is a sign of how far commissioning processes have come. We have reached a point where it seems shocking that deaf people wouldn’t be involved in helping to design the way their services are run. Not too long ago this would have been par for the course.

See the deputations and subsequent debate here http://edinburgh.public-i.tv/core/share/open/webcast/0/0/560/213721/0/0/start_time/1234000.

The initial conversation on 3rd November can be viewed here http://edinburgh.public-i.tv/core/share/open/webcast/0/0/560/213720/0/0/start_time/554000

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google
  • LinkedIn
  • Email

Tagged With: Coproduction, Councillors, Deaf Action, Deputation

Have you thought about supporting EVOC by becoming a member?

Membership of EVOC is open to all organisations and individuals. Find out how to join EVOC

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

View Blogs by Category

  • Director's blog
  • Guest Post
  • Network
  • Recovery Essentials
  • Staff Posts

I want. . . .

  • The latest news
  • Upcoming training courses
  • Advertise my news
  • Attend an event
  • Join EVOC Membership

About EVOC

  • Board & Trustees
  • Meet the EVOC Team
  • Edinburgh Third Sector Interface
  • Accessibility
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy

Contact Us

EVOC
1st Floor
14 Ashley Place
Edinburgh, EH6 5PX

T: 0131 555 9100
F: 0131 555 9101
E: info@evoc.org.uk

Facebook
Twitter

Latest Tweets

  • Have you ever wondered what it's like to be a trustee for a charity? EVOC staff member, Georgia reflects on the exp… https://t.co/ornQdvVC8D Yesterday at 9:05 am
  • Did you know that the Edinburgh and Lothian Trust Fund can provide grants for individuals of up to £250?… https://t.co/XjwLGg4s7g 24 April 2018 4:15 pm
  • We are delighted to announce that our #EVOC15 project is being supported by @heritagelottery… https://t.co/9pwidPFf5h 24 April 2018 8:05 am
EFQM - Committed to excellence 2016
Quality Scotland Logo
OSRC Registered Charity - SC009944

Copyright © 2018 · Edinburgh Voluntary Organisations' Council is a company limited by guarantee No. SC173582 and is a registered Scottish charity No. SC009944.

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.